Sunday, September 27, 2026

The market scales puzzle

 The values of the 4 weights must be 1, 3, 9, 27! The first 4 powers of 3.

I've never used a two-pan scale, and I'm mostly aware of how it works, but I couldn't quite wrap my head around the weights I would need. So I started with the question about a one-pan scale. That one felt very intuitive. I would need the weights 1, 2, 4, 8, 16. Those add up to a weight of 31, and you can create any weight from 1-31 with just those numbers. From there, I mulled over the two-pan scale, trying to make it work with different powers of 2. However, no matter how I played with the numbers, it didn't seem to quite work to make 40 with just 4 weights. I tried powers of 4, and those numbers went way too big! So, continuing with the idea of powers, I tried powers of 3, and it added up to 40, which was a good sign. And testing out different potential weights, it worked. I realized this worked because there's only 3 possible positions each weight can be in, whereas with the one-pan scale, theres only 2. 

I think this problem could be extended to different weight numbers and numbers weights. Students could also compare one-pan vs two-pan scales and investigate why powers of 2 work for one, while powers of 3 work for the other. This connects to number theory and bases because the weights are powers of 2 or 3, depending on the scale type. The one-pan scale relates to base 2, where each weight is either used or not used, while the two-pan scale relates to base 3, where each weight can be placed on the left, right, or not used!

1 comment:

  1. I found it interesting that you started with the one-pan scale because it felt more familiar, and then used that understanding to approach the two-pan problem. It made me think about how students can build on what they already know when facing an unfamiliar problem.

    ReplyDelete

Numbers With Personality

My first stop was where they mentioned: “synesthesia affects only about 4 per cent of the population, and OLP is a very small subset”. I was...